I feel like GTA is definitely more clunky than those two games. Might be because the animation feels wrong for some reason.

If there’s is a reason for making it that way, it’s not really dumb.

Yeah, no one plays GTA for the gameplay mechanics, they play them for the RP or the chaos, or both.

Part of the reason it shard to change the system is because of resistance from the waiters who make a lot of money from tips, so yes, not tipping does help change the system.